Chinese Avant-Garde
On 5 February 1989, the China/Avant-Garde exhibition opened at the China Art Gallery in Beijing. It was the show where the artists of the Chinese avant-garde stood together in the state's own museum. About two hours after the opening, a young artist named Xiao Lu fired a gun at her own work, Dialogue. The exhibition was closed on the spot. This incident later came to be called the first shot of Tiananmen, but that name was given after people knew about June, four months later. This map puts the start of the band on this day. The shape of the pictures becomes clear only after 1989. The critic Li Xianting read the paintings of this period as showing reality as it is, after meaning has melted away. Now a word about names. This map has kept writing that the names of styles usually begin as insults. Chinese avant-garde did not go that way. The one who named it was Li Xianting, the critic who was introducing these artists abroad. Wanshi Xianshi Zhuyi (Cynical Realism) is said to first appear in his essay in the Hong Kong magazine Twenty-First Century in February 1992 (some sources say 1991, so the year is divided). Li is said to have explained that he chose the word cynical as the equivalent of Popi Niu Er, the ruffian in Water Margin. The other term, Zhengzhi Bopu (Political Pop), is said to have settled as a word while preparing a 1993 exhibition in Hong Kong, and the common account is that Li named it. The insults came after the names were given. Some Western critics saw it as a copy of Western Pop, and one wrote of deja vu. There is also the side of the one who had a name pressed on him. Yue Minjun denies that his paintings are Cynical Realism. He does not accept being grouped. There are clear parts and unclear parts in where it came from, too. Wang Guangyi's Great Criticism series borrowed the heavily exaggerated muscular figures and flat colors of Cultural Revolution posters and overlaid logos of Western products such as Coca-Cola. That he borrowed from the posters is the settled view. On the other hand, I found no primary source this time saying it came from Warhol. It was Western critics who said it looked like Western Pop, and how far there was influence differs from artist to artist; that is as much as the sources can say. This map draws a line from Pop Art to this band, but it is a line drawn at the weight of a personal view, not of settled fact. 1993 was the year this band went out into the world. From January to February, in Hong Kong, came the exhibition China's New Art, Post-1989. It was curated by Johnson Chang and Li Xianting, and one researcher counted that about 45 percent of the works in the catalogue were Political Pop or Cynical Realism. In June, Wang Guangyi, Fang Lijun and others stood in Passage to the Orient, a special exhibition at the 45th Venice Biennale (the number of Chinese artists is given as 14 in some places and 10 in others). The one who paved the road to Venice was Francesca Dal Lago, who worked at the Italian embassy in Beijing, and the record says it came from her wish to make these people known abroad. After that comes the story of prices. Yue Minjun's The Execution is a painting from 1995. In October 2007 it sold at Sotheby's in London for 2,932,500 pounds, then the highest auction price for Chinese contemporary art. The artist himself says Tiananmen was a spark for the idea, but he asks that it not be seen as a painting of Tiananmen. Among painters of the same period, there are some who fit neither name. From 1993, Zhang Xiaogang began painting the Bloodline series, based on family photographs from the time of the Cultural Revolution, and showed four of them at Venice in 1995. Liu Ye met Miffy in Amsterdam in 1998 and has painted her since as a kind of alter ego. This band is a place that holds people inside the names and people outside them. The artists of an exhibition that was closed in two hours stood side by side in Hong Kong and Venice four years later. I think it was because there were people who came from outside to find them, and people who introduced them outward (this reading is my own).